Call or Text +1 (213) 319-5497 for Immediate Assistance

Skip to main content
LA real estate news

Woodland Hills Country Club lawsuit: housing groups sue LA over mountain lion ruling

Policy & lawPublished 7 min read

By the Ascend Cleaning team, Los Angeles

Three pro-housing groups sued Los Angeles on Nov. 16 to force approval of 398 homes on part of the Woodland Hills Country Club, which the city ruled is mountain lion habitat. Here is what the suit asks, the fines at stake and what comes next.

A collared mountain lion known as P-64 walks out of a concrete culvert in the Santa Monica Mountains, captured by a National Park Service camera.
Photo by National Park Service, Public domain, via Wikimedia Commons

The short version

Three pro-housing groups sued the City of Los Angeles on Monday, Nov. 16, to force approval of 398 homes on part of the Woodland Hills Country Club. YIMBY Law, Californians for Homeownership and the California Housing Defense Fund filed the case in Los Angeles County Superior Court. They ask a judge to set aside the city's Aug. 20 ruling that the golf course is habitat for protected mountain lions and to order the project approved under a state fast-track law, City News Service reported.

"If the city does not correct its violation and approve the project, it will face severe punishment," Ryan Patterson, an attorney for YIMBY Law, told LAist. He said taxpayers could owe up to $20 million plus attorney's fees if the city loses. LA City Planning declined to comment, citing pending litigation. No hearing date has been reported.

How the Woodland Hills Country Club fight got here

Newport Beach-based Arrimus Capital bought the century-old club at 21150 Dumetz Road in 2020. In November 2025 it applied to build 398 homes on about 20 of the property's 93 acres, a plan the city calls the 4868 Canoga Avenue project. The mix includes 175 single-family homes plus apartments, with some units reserved for lower-income households. Reports differ on the exact apartment and affordable counts.

The owner applied under AB 2011, a 2022 state law that lets qualifying mixed-income housing along wide "commercial corridor" streets win approval through a ministerial review. That means staff check the plans against fixed standards, with no public hearings and no review under the California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA), according to LA City Planning's implementation memo.

On Aug. 20, planners ruled the site ineligible because it is habitat for a protected species, one of the law's few exclusions. In late October, the state housing department told the city its reasoning did not hold up, and on Oct. 30 the owner's attorney sent a 60-day notice of intent to sue. We covered those steps in our earlier report on the 60-day notice and possible fines.

What the lawsuit claims

The suit argues that AB 2011 entitles housing that meets clear state standards to streamlined approval without years of discretionary hearings. According to City News Service, it also alleges the city spent most of 2026 hunting for a way around the law. The plaintiffs point to a council vote to study narrowing Canoga Avenue, which would affect the street-width test, and to an effort to reclassify golf courses as vacant land that city attorneys judged legally weak.

The Los Angeles Times reported that the groups also invoke the Housing Accountability Act, a 1982 state law that limits when cities can reject housing that meets their rules. Per the Times, the complaint calls the denial "political interference by the local councilmember and bad faith obstruction by the Department of City Planning."

Why can advocacy groups sue over someone else's project? Under the Housing Accountability Act, the applicant, a person eligible to live in the project, or a "housing organization" can bring a case, according to a state guidance memo on the law. A housing organization can only challenge a denial and must have commented to the city before the decision. None of the reports we reviewed lists the developer as a plaintiff.

"A golf course is obviously not a mountain lion habitat," said Zachary Pitts, YIMBY Action's Los Angeles director, in a statement quoted by City News Service.

The habitat question at the center of the case

Two days before the suit, the evidence fight got fresh footage. The Santa Monica Mountains Conservancy said a home security camera recorded an uncollared mountain lion on Gaona Street, alongside the course, at 9:55 p.m. on Friday, Nov. 13. A second lion was recorded about a mile west the next morning. Executive director Joseph Edmiston said the video "shows both the value of Woodland Hills habitat areas and that these magnificent animals are pressed for space."

The legal status of these cats has also shifted. In February, the state Fish and Game Commission voted unanimously that the Southern California and Central Coast mountain lion population warrants protection as a threatened species under the California Endangered Species Act, the state wildlife department announced. The population had candidate protections since 2020, and Allen Matkins notes that it includes lions in the Santa Monica Mountains, Simi Hills and Santa Susana Mountains.

A listing does not settle the case on its own. Land use firm Cox Castle wrote that the listing does not by itself let cities sidestep housing laws, and that habitat findings must rest on evidence about the specific project site. It pointed to the Bay Area town of Woodside, which backed away from a mountain lion argument against SB 9 projects after the state attorney general called it unfounded.

The state housing department takes a similar view. Its Oct. 28 letter, signed by Melinda Coy, said the city's rationale "appears to improperly expand the statutory standard, effectively undermining the intent of AB 2011, and is not supported by the law." LAist quoted the letter as saying, "The city must demonstrate that the site actually serves as a habitat, for which the report offers no such evidence." The department has authority to enforce AB 2011 and asked the city for a written reply by Nov. 25.

The city's side and the neighbors' concerns

Councilmember Bob Blumenfield, who represents Woodland Hills, says the city is applying the law as written. "The scientific evidence is indisputable," he told LAist, adding that experts including the Mountains Recreation and Conservation Authority "have definitively concluded that this site is habitat for mountain lions."

The Westside Current reported that Blumenfield's office also cited a letter from National Park Service researchers about how the developer described their 2021 study. His spokesman, Jake Flynn, told the paper that Blumenfield does not oppose developing the site, only the expedited process. The developer's biologist, Matt South, disputed the habitat finding in July, according to Canyon News.

Many neighbors focus on fire. Most of the club sits in a state-designated very high fire hazard severity zone. AB 2011 bars fast-track approval on vacant land in those zones, but supporters argue a working golf course is not vacant. "If anything happens up here that blocks any of these roads, all of us can't get out," John Walker, president of the Woodland Hills Homeowners Organization, told LAist.

Not every council member backed the city's approach. When the council voted 11-1 in August to draft new rules for agricultural-zoned land, Councilmember Nithya Raman voted no. "The city should not change the rules in the middle of a submitted project being reviewed," she said at the time, adding that it "raises legal exposure for the city." Raman is now mayor-elect.

What is at stake in fines

The Housing Accountability Act gives courts strong tools. If a city loses and does not comply within 60 days, the court must impose a fine of at least $10,000 per unit, paid into a housing trust fund, according to the state guidance memo. If the court finds bad faith, which includes actions that are frivolous or entirely without merit, the fine is multiplied by five and the court can order the project approved.

For 398 homes, that works out to about $3.98 million at the minimum and about $19.9 million at five times that rate, close to the $20 million figure Patterson cited. A separate law, AB 712, in effect since Jan. 1, 2026, raises penalties when a city ignored a prior state warning. City News Service reported that the housing department's October letter serves as that warning.

What happens next

  • Nov. 25: the city's deadline to answer the state housing department.
  • Around Dec. 29: the end of the owner's 60-day notice window, counted from Oct. 30. The owner could then file its own suit.
  • December: new leadership. LAist reports a new city attorney, Marissa Roy, and a new councilmember for the area, Barri Worth Girvan, take office next month. Pitts told LAist his hope is that the city settles and approves the project. No settlement talks have been reported.
  • No date yet: a first court hearing.

What it means for LA agents

  1. Treat the project as contested. For buyers and sellers near Dumetz Road and Canoga Avenue, describe the 398 homes as proposed and in litigation, not approved.
  2. Expect wildlife and fire questions. The new lion video will circulate. Pull the state fire hazard map and insurance quotes early for Woodland Hills hillside listings.
  3. Watch the precedent. A ruling on whether a golf course can be "habitat" or "vacant" could shape other AB 2011 sites on wide Valley streets. Clients weighing land deals should have counsel review fast-track options.
  4. Track the calendar. The Nov. 25 reply and the late-December notice window are the next checkpoints, along with any change in approach under the new mayor and councilmember.

Are you an LA realtor?

Work with Ascend for your next listing. We handle pre-listing deep cleans, move-out cleans for vacant homes and touch-ups before open houses, anywhere in Los Angeles.