The short version
A federal jury in Los Angeles has convicted Jonathan Rinderknecht of starting the fire that grew into the 2025 Palisades Fire. The Palisades Fire verdict came Friday afternoon, Nov. 20, after a retrial. The first trial ended in a hung jury in June. The Associated Press reported that the 30-year-old former Uber driver was found guilty on both federal counts.
For people who own, buy or sell property in Pacific Palisades, the verdict answers one question: who lit the fire. It does not answer the question most owners care about in money terms, which is whether the City of Los Angeles, the Department of Water and Power or the State of California must pay for the losses. That fight is in a separate civil case. It is still moving, and nobody expects a quick end.
How the case got here
The criminal case does not center on Jan. 7, 2025, the day the Palisades Fire tore through the neighborhood. It centers on New Year's Day. Just after midnight on Jan. 1, a small brush fire started on a hillside above the Palisades. Investigators named it the Lachman Fire, after a nearby street. NBC News reported that sensors detected it at 12:12 a.m. and that firefighters put it out after it burned roughly five to eight acres.
Prosecutors said the fire never fully died. It kept smoldering underground in root systems for six days. Then the Santa Ana winds pushed it back to the surface on Jan. 7. Fire investigators call this a holdover fire, meaning a later fire that is a continuation of an earlier one that seemed to be out.
According to CAL FIRE's incident page, the Palisades Fire burned 23,448 acres, destroyed 6,845 structures, damaged 975 more and killed 12 people. It was not fully contained until Jan. 31, 2025.
Federal agents arrested Rinderknecht in October 2025. The Justice Department's case page lists the filings. The first trial ended in June 2026 when jurors split 10 to 2 in favor of acquittal. Prosecutors then filed a superseding indictment, which is a revised set of charges that replaces the earlier one. They dropped a third count and narrowed another before the retrial opened in early November.
What the jury decided
Rinderknecht was convicted of two crimes under federal arson law. The first is destruction of property by means of fire, which after the rewrite covers only the Lachman Fire. The second is arson affecting property used in interstate commerce, which addresses the Palisades Fire itself. Federal law reaches these fires because of the kind of property involved, which is why the case is in federal court and not state court.
Because the jury convicted on the second count, it accepted the government's theory that the Palisades Fire grew out of the New Year's Day fire. That is the holdover finding, now backed by a jury verdict and not only by an investigator's report.
Two rules shaped the trial. The judge told jurors not to weigh how well the Los Angeles Fire Department fought the Lachman Fire. She also barred any mention of the first trial. NBC News reported that sentencing is set for March 17, 2027, and that Rinderknecht faces a minimum of five years and a maximum of 40 years in prison.
The defense says the case is circumstantial. Attorney Steve Haney argued that the hillside was open to the public for days before police closed it and that fireworks could explain the ignition. The Los Angeles Times reported on the verdict and the reaction outside the courthouse, and Haney has said he plans to appeal.
What the verdict means for the lawsuits
Most fire survivors are not waiting on the criminal case for money. They are waiting on a large consolidated civil case in Los Angeles Superior Court against the city, DWP, the state and others. The Palisadian-Post explains the main legal theories:
- Inverse condemnation. A claim under the California Constitution that a public entity must pay when its public works, such as a water system or power lines, cause private property damage. Owners do not have to prove the government acted unreasonably.
- Public nuisance. A claim that a public entity let a condition exist that harmed the community, such as overgrown city-owned lots.
- Dangerous condition of public property. A claim under state law that public property was in an unsafe state that caused the harm.
The allegations include the empty Santa Ynez Reservoir, a DWP reservoir in the Palisades that was drained for repairs and held no water when the fire hit. They also include brush on city-owned lots, DWP power lines and the claim that the Lachman Fire was never fully put out on state parkland.
Here is where the verdict matters. Much of the case against the state turns on whether the Lachman Fire was really extinguished. The Palisadian-Post noted that the criminal outcome could bear on those causation arguments. A jury has now found, beyond a reasonable doubt, that the Palisades Fire was a holdover of the Lachman Fire. That lines up with what plaintiffs have argued.
Still, a criminal verdict does not decide civil liability. Westside Current reported that the holdover finding "does not resolve the civil lawsuits" and that the city and state deny liability. The same report said the city and DWP agreed in August to enter mediation, a private negotiation led by a neutral third party, with talks expected to begin in early October. The state did not agree to join. We found no public report of a settlement as of this writing.
What the verdict does not settle
The firefighting question is still open, just not in this courtroom. In October, the LA Times reported that an independent investigation commissioned by Gov. Gavin Newsom found the Fire Department ignored multiple warnings that the Lachman Fire was still smoldering. The department acknowledged missteps.
Local officials made the same point after the verdict. City Councilmember Traci Park, who represents the Palisades, told reporters the verdict closes one piece of the story. Fox News quoted her as saying, "I don't think this takes heat off of the authorities," and pointing to failures in water systems, evacuation routes and staffing.
Prosecutors framed it differently. First Assistant U.S. Attorney Bill Essayli said after the verdict that the question of who was responsible now has an answer, according to NBC News.
Where the Palisades market stands
The verdict lands in a neighborhood still deciding whether to rebuild or sell. Crosstown reported on Nov. 16 that the city issued 1,055 new building permits in the Palisades through October. Before the fire, the area saw roughly 50 a year. Only 76 certificates of occupancy, the final sign-off that lets a family move in, had been issued.
Values have moved too. Using county assessor data, Crosstown found the average Palisades property value fell 19%, from $2.33 million to $1.89 million, between 2024 and 2025. Neighboring Brentwood rose 3.2% over the same period. Other trackers count permits and sales differently, so treat these as one snapshot.
Crosstown also reported that many owners were underinsured and that rebuilding now costs far more than before the fire. For a lot of families, a civil settlement is the money that would close that gap.
What happens next
- March 17, 2027. Sentencing in federal court. An appeal could follow.
- Civil case. The consolidated case is in discovery, the stage where each side gathers evidence. The Palisadian-Post has said a settlement could take one to three more years.
- Jan. 7, 2027. The deadline for the city to adopt a resolution of intention for a Palisades disaster recovery district under SB 782, a state law that lets local governments fund rebuilding work in fire areas. The Palisadian-Post reported that the plan cleared a council committee and still needs a full council vote.
What this means for LA agents
- Expect the question at every showing. Buyers will ask whether the verdict changes anything. The accurate answer is that it settles who started the fire, not who pays for the damage.
- Do not price in a settlement. No court has found the city, DWP or state liable, and the timeline is measured in years. A lot's value should rest on comps, rebuild costs and insurance, not on a possible payout.
- Ask sellers about their claims early. Many Palisades owners are plaintiffs. They should talk with their own attorney about how a sale affects a pending claim before a listing goes live.
- Use current data, and say where it comes from. Permit counts, assessed values and sale prices vary by source. Name the source when you quote a number to a client.
- Watch the recovery district vote. A council vote before Jan. 7 could shape how fast streets and infrastructure come back, which matters for both rebuild and resale timelines.

